"Ruby Sparks" a flawed but clever indie gem
The term Manic Pixie Dream Girl, coined in 2005 by AV Club film critic Nathan Rabin, refers to a female character whose bubbly sensibility, behaviors and attitudes push the young male lead toward a more rewarding understanding of life and love. It's a stock character, most commonly found in indie movies and Zooey Deschanel's entire career, that's less of a person and more of a screenwriting tool.
Upon seeing the trailer and reading the synopsis for "Ruby Sparks," one would be forgiven for expecting overwhelming amounts of MPDG-related quirkiness to be shoved down their throats. The fact that the film is directed by Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris, the husband/wife duo that created the now indie-cliché bible, "Little Miss Sunshine," was more cause for concern.
However, I'm happy to say "Ruby Sparks" pleasantly surprised me, evolving the MPDG trope into something smarter and more clever than the marketing would have moviegoers believe.
The film follows Calvin (named assumably after the equally imaginative young boy from "Calvin and Hobbes"), a young novelist who is struggling to come up with the subject for his next novel. The fact that he has been anointed a genius after his debut book doesn't help matters. His search for a topic stops when he begins seeing a beautiful, charming girl named Ruby (Zoe Kazan, who also wrote the screenplay) in his dreams.
Thanks to power of his imagination and his typewriter, however, the girl of his dreams becomes the very real girl who lives in his apartment, much to the befuddlement of Calvin and his older brother/confidante (Chris Messina).
The first act of "Ruby Sparks" goes through the creation of Ruby, laying down some of the clichés of the MPDG. Calvin is brooding and uncomfortable with society, especially women (featured in a brief appearance with Alia Shawkat, most known as Maeby from "Arrested Development"). Ruby, when glimpsed in Calvin's dreams, is all quirky cutesiness.
It's trite but presented well. Paul Dano, the colorblind mute son from "Little Miss Sunshine," brings his usual strangely antic yet composed energy to the main role, and Kazan is charmingly effervescent without becoming draining. Elliott Gould also makes several pleasant and humorous early appearances as Calvin's psychologist and writing coach.
Dayton and Faris also tell the story without laying the whimsy and quirk on thick. For instance, a daydream recap of Ruby's life history hazily projected onto the psychologist's ceiling is delightful and clever without trying too hard. Ruby's gradual appearance into reality – her lingerie keeps randomly appearing in Calvin's apartment for no reason – is mysterious, intriguing and good for a few laughs.
As "Ruby Sparks" continues on, however, the story becomes far less standard. Ruby may start as Calvin's dream girl come to life, but he soon starts discovering that she wants a life of her own. Ruby wants to grow and evolve, whereas Calvin wants her to stay the way he made and pictured her. Unbeknownst to Ruby, since she's technically a figment of his imagination, Calvin also has the ability to make her behave the way he wants.
It's a clever play on the MPDG cliché. Screenwriters, such as Calvin, write these fictitious dream girls, but what would happen if they were real people, not just creations of their own hopes and desires? The story isn't just limited to the writing process. The wish for control in his dream relationship with Ruby becomes a statement on relationships in general. The person you start with might not be the same one in a year's time, like it or not, and changing them or hoping for the past will kill the romance faster than save it.
"Ruby Sparks" isn't perfect. A mid-movie trip to a jungle palace created by Calvin's parents (Annette Bening and Antonio Banderas) falls into the trap of forced indie quirk that it previously had ably avoided. Plus, the ending wraps up a bit too nicely, especially considering Calvin and Ruby's last, slightly terrifying moments together.
Much like a relationship, though, if you are able to overlook the minor flaws, you might find something smart and sweet to fall in love with.
Talkbacks
![]() |
No Talkbacks for this article. Post your comment/review now |
Facebook comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Matt Mueller
It's clear as black and white: "Frances Ha" is an absolute charmer
Published June 18, 2013
Noah Baumbach's 2005 breakthrough "The Squid and the Whale" is a great movie, but it should come with a warning. The dialogue and characters are so cutting and acidic, I was left looking for a Band-Aid when it was all done. Eight years and a couple more scathing features later, Baumbach delivers "Frances Ha," a sweet Woody Allen-esque comedy that his honest, funny, acute screenplays can come with a light, tender touch, as well.
Five reasons why "World War Z" is guaranteed to flop
Published June 18, 2013
Even if the movie is good enough to bring an captivated tear to George A. Romero's eye, the odds are very much against "World War Z." Here are the five main reasons why this upcoming zombie spectacular is almost guaranteed to be a pain in the neck for Pitt and company by the end of the weekend.
Forget birds or planes: Superman's return in "Man of Steel" doesn't soar
Published June 14, 2013
While director Zack Snyder (the Green Bay native behind "300") outdoes even himself in terms of epic visual spectacle, his attempt to churn out a moody, serious Superman story in the vein of Christopher Nolan - who serves as producer and provided the story alongside Batman collaborator David S. Goyer - lands with a thud.
"This Is The End" a hilarious bro-pocalypse of biblical proportions
Published June 12, 2013
If "This Is The End" is any evidence, it seems we know how James Franco, Jonah Hill, Seth Rogen, Craig Robinson, Jay Baruchel and Danny McBride would bid the planet adieu: They'd have a whole lot of drugged up, profane, wild fun. If this is what the end of the world as we know it looks like, to borrow a phrase from R.E.M., I feel fine.
Glorified Google ad "The Internship" is a full-time failure
Published June 11, 2013
Dear readers, I have seen our savior, and its name is Google. Google is a shining, six-letter, multi-colored beacon of light and hope in these dark, difficult times, and its technological wizardry brings joy to the hearts of millions. All hail our wonderful search engine leader. All hail it indeed. At least, that was my main takeaway coming out of "The Internship," a woefully humor-devoid workplace comedy starring Vince Vaughn and Owen Wilson.
Adventure lovers should set sail for "Kon-Tiki"
Published June 10, 2013
As it turns out, Ang Lee's "Life of Pi" wasn't the only recent Oscar nominee with its eyes set on the high seas. In the Best Foreign Film category, there was Norway's "Kon-Tiki." And while there might not be any disgruntled tigers in sight, the real-life journey of legendary explorer Thor Heyerdahl and his motley crew is just as beautiful and wondrous to behold. I guess there's enough ocean in the world for two great waterlogged adventures.
"Love Is All You Need" needs some new material
Published June 9, 2013
A movie called "Love Is All You Need" is clearly a movie that does not mess around. Most films may try to weave the message or theme into the story with some nuance, but not "Love Is All You Need." It's right there in the title: The characters in this movie will learn that love is, in fact, all you need. With a blunt title like that, what else could you possibly expect? Not much apparently.
Capable cast battles indie excesses in "The Kings of Summer"
Published June 8, 2013
The phrase "Sundance darling" comes with a bit more skepticism for me nowadays. Sure, the label can sometimes be pinned to a really honest, hilarious and emotionally satisfying film. Other times, it's stuck onto a movie that's both overworked and over-quirked. "The Kings of Summer" swings to both sides of that pendulum, its clever jokes and earnest look at growing-up constantly fighting against the pull of its indie indulgences.
"Mud" finds greatness in gritty, grimy growing-up tale
Published June 7, 2013
"Mud" serves as the third film for writer-director Jeff Nichols, but this one comes with something new: expectations.
Skylight's timeless "Porgy and Bess" a grand exit for director Theisen
Published June 6, 2013
Times have changed mightily since "Porgy and Bess" first took the stage in 1935 (though large, all-black productions are still rare in the arts, both stage and screen), but as staged and performed by the Skylight's remarkable cast and crew, the original production's sweaty South Carolina grit and gorgeous moments of massive, raw emotion seem well in tact with rarely any trace of cobwebs.
Like Us
Follow Us













